ANNIE 2007
 
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
 
PARTICIPATION
 

   Abstract Submission

  For Manuscripts Preparation
      Keyword List
      Instructions
      Copyright Form
  Referee Report Form
  Registration Form
 

 
Back To ANNIE Homepage
 

NOTICE! Due to recent server changes made by the UMR IT Department, the online referee report submission form is not functioning properly.
Please mail or fax your report to:

Dr. Cihan Dagli
Smart Engineering Systems Laboratory
Dept. of Engineering Management
University of Missouri - Rolla
1870 Miner Circle
Rolla, MO 65409-0370
P: (573) 341-6576 F: (573)341-6567

 We are sorry for the inconvenience this problem may cause. Thank you for your patience.

ON-LINE REVIEW SUBMISSION COMING SOON!

 

            REFEREE REPORT FORM
SMART ENGINEERING SYSTEM DESIGN : NEURAL NETWORKS, FUZZY LOGIC,

EVOLUTIONARY PROGRAMMING, COMPLEX SYSTEMS AND DATA MINING

PART I

PAPER CODE:

AUTHOR(S):

TITLE:


Please give your overall evaluation of the paper by marking an appropriate number. Feel free to use the margins of the manuscript for short comments and typographical errors that will be useful for the author in preparing camera ready manuscript. You can use the reverse side of this page for your written comments for improving the paper.
  False                             True
Paper makes a good contribution to the
engineering applications and/or
theory of neural networks.
 1 2 3 4 5
Paper can be classified as a(n):  
   Original Research paper.
 1 2 3 4 5
   Conceptual model paper. 1 2 3 4 5
   Application paper. 1 2 3 4 5
   Theoretical paper. 1 2 3 4 5
   Review or Discussion paper. 1 2 3 4 5
Paper is logically and technically correct. 1 2 3 4 5
Paper is free of mathematical errors. 1 2 3 4 5
References are adequate. 1 2 3 4 5
Rating of paper in comparison to similar paper published in refereed proceedings:
  
Below Average
Average
Above Average
Excellent
  

PART II

Comments and Recommendations:


OVERALL RECOMMENDATION

    Accept without any changes.
    Unacceptable. (Give reasons in Part II)
    Accept with modifications.

BEST PAPER AWARD NOMINATION

As an organizing committee we would like to recognize researchers that contributed to the advancement of research in Engineering Applications of Computational Intelligence. We will present a best paper award to the authors of two papers with best technical merit, one in the area of "Novel Smart Engineering Design Applications" and the other in the area of " Theoretical Developments In Techniques". The selection of these papers will be done through an Award Committee made up of members of the Organizing Committee and other senior researchers in the field. Only those papers nominated by the referees will be considered.

Please answer the following questions for an award nomination regarding the paper:

  •  
    I nominate the paper for the award for "Novel Smart Engineering Design Applications" with best technical merit.
    • I nominate the paper for the award for "Theoretical Developments In Techniques" with best technical merit.
Referee:
Address:
Email:
WWW:
Please double check the referee report and press this button to submit the report:

.


You can also mail your report to:
Dr. Cihan Dagli
Smart Engineering Systems Laboratory
Dept. of Engineering Management
University of Missouri - Rolla
1870 Miner Circle
Rolla, MO 65409-0370
P: (573) 341-6576 F: (573)341-6268
 

email: webmaster