Conor Watkins And J. David Rogers
Colorado Plateau Research
Vermilion Cliffs, AZ Landsliding
Possible Causes of Slope Instability


Toreva block style landslides along the Vermilion Cliffs as viewed from Hwy 89A near House Rock


POSSIBLE CAUSES OF SLOPE INSTABILITY ALONG THE VERMILION CLIFFS

  • A wetter climate during the Pleistocene likely heightened groundwater levels within the cliffs.  This may have led to gross instability because of reduced effective stress and loss of cohesion in the the Chinle and and Moenkopi Formations.
  • Saturation and strength loss of the Petrified Forest Member of the Chinle Formation might have been caused by lava dams in the western Grand Canyon. These dams impounded reservoirs with a pool elevation of up to 1200 m (4000 ft), easily saturating the base of the Vermilion Cliffs.  This effect was likely more pronounced at the eastern end of the cliffs near Lee's Ferry, which are at a significantly lower elevation than the western portion near House Rock, AZ.
  • Evidence suggests that some lava dams failed catastrophically.  Pore pressure imbalances caused by rapid drawdown during these failures may have triggered the earth flows common near Lee's Ferry.
  • At least three of the dozen or more lava dams inpacted the Vermilion Cliffs Region.  Reservoir induced seismicity caused by the filling of such large lakes may have played a role in triggering the landslides.
  • Seismic activity related to nearby volcanism may have been instrumental in triggering the slides.
  • Strain softening caused by relaxation of slopes may have acted to reduce the strength of the Chinle Shales in combination with other processes.  It is possible that straining of the Chinle Formation is responsible for the open joint planes seen near the edge of the Paria Plateau atop the cliffs.


INFLUENCE OF LAVA DAMS IN WESTERN GRAND CANYON


The strata comprising the Vermilion Cliffs and Paria Plateau dip northeasterly, between the East Kaibab and Echo Monoclines.  Relief increases easterly, towards the Colorado River.  This diagram is borrowed from Strahler (1940).


Relief along the Vermilion and Echo Cliffs increases as they approach the Colorado River.  This view shows Marble Canyon as seen from Navajo Bridge.

The higher Pleistocene lava dams in western Grand Canyon created reservoirs that extended well beyond Lee’s Ferry, placing the base of the easternmost cliffs under more than 300 meter of water.



These maps from Hamblin (1994) show a wide and close view of Prospect Lake, the largest lava dammed lake in the Grand Canyon.  The lake had an approximate depth of 699 meters (2330 feet) and extended nearly to the Utah-Colorado border, over 300 miles upstream.  Fenton et al. (2004) summarized radiometric dates ranging from 600 to over 1800 ka for the Prospect Lava Dam; with around 600 ka accepted as most reliable.

POSSIBLE INFLUENCE OF A WETTER CLIMATE AND STRAINING OF CHINLE SHALES


It is possible that a wetter climate during pluvials of the Pleistocene led to the saturation and failure of slopes along the Vermilion and Echo Cliffs.  Both Strahler (1940) and Ahnert (1960) make mention of open joints in the Navajo Sandstone on the Paria Plateau above the Vermilion Cliffs.  The open joints could channel large quantities of water into the underlying formations, resulting in a reduction of their strength.  These open joints may be caused by the straining of the underlying Chinle shales.


This photo shows a promontory along the Vermilion Cliffs that appears to be an incipient slide.  Notice the small scarp developed behind the promontory.  This indicates some movement and deformation in the underlying Chinle Shales.  An older slide rests against the front of this block, possibly preventing a complete failure.  This is along the cliffs near Lee's Ferry.

Questions or comments on this page?
E-mail Dr. J David Rogers at rogersda@umr.edu
or Conor Watkins at cwatkin@umr.edu.